state seal
 dobi title gif
search  
Home > Consumer Information > Insurance Topics > Auto > Contact Information - Auto Insurers in New Jersey
Insurers that Write Private Passenger Auto in New Jersey

This list includes all insurance companies that write private passenger auto insurance and companies newly admitted to New Jersey. Please see the notes next to each insurer's name for any restrictions on new applicants.

Looking for the Assigned Risk Market?
Looking for Motorcycle Insurers?
Looking for Specialty Insurers?

Insurer

Telephone
Number

Direct Writer or Contact Agent and Web site

AAA Mid-Atlantic Group

  • AAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company of NJ
    • Keystone Insurance Company
1-800-542-9544

Direct (AAA)
Agent (Keystone)
www.aaamidatlantic.com

Allstate Group

  • Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
  • Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company
 1-866-222-4586

Agent
www.allstate.com
American International Group
  • AIG National Insurance Company
  • AIG Premier Insurance Company
  • AIIC of DE
  • AIIC of NJ (not accepting any new business)

1-877-244-4288
(AIG National)

1-866-856-6858
(AIG Premier)

1-800-807-9458
1-800-241-1188
(Customer Service)

Agent (AIG National)
www.aig4auto.com

Agent (AIG Premier)
www.aigpcg.com

Direct (AIIC of DE, AIIC of NJ)
www.aigdirect.com
Amica Property and Casualty Insurance Company 1-888-592-6422 Direct
www.amica.com
Atlantic Mutual Group
  • Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company
  • Centennial Insurance Company
1-800-444-6161

Agent
www.atlanticmutual.com

Balboa Group

  • Balboa Insurance company
  • Meritplan Insurance Company
1-800-444-6161 Direct
www.atlanticmutual.com
Chubb Group
  • Chubb Insurance Company of NJ
  • Pacific Indemnity Company

1-866-324-8222 (Marketing)

1-800-252-4670
(NJ Claims)

Agent
www.chubb.com
Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange (CURE) (formerly NJCURE) 1-800-535-2873 Direct
www.njcure.com
Consumer First Insurance Company 973-470-9843 Agent
Countryway Insurance Company (not accepting any new business) (membership company for farmers; may not accept all applicants) 315-634-5200 Agent
Electric Insurance Company (may not accept all applicants) 1-800-342-5342 Direct
www.electricinsurance.com

Encompass Group

  • Encompass Property and Casualty Insurance Company of NJ
  • Encompass Insurance Company of NJ (not accepting any new business)
 1-800-262-5238

Agent
www.encompassinsurance.com

Esurance Group

  • Esurance Insurance Company (not accepting new business)
  • Esurance Insurance Company of New Jersey
1-800-378-7262

Direct
www.esurance.com
Farm Family Casualty Insurance Company (membership company for farmers; may not accept all applicants) 1-800-843-3276
518-431-5000		 Direct
www.farmfamily.com
Fireman's Fund Indemnity Corporation 1-800-523-9500 Agent
www.FFIC.com
Founders Insurance Company (Penn National Group) 717-234-4941
1-800-388-4764

Agent
www.pennnationalinsurance.com

GEICO Group

  • Government Employees Insurance Company
  • GEICO Casualty Insurance Company
  • GEICO Indemnity Company
1-800-861-8380

Direct
www.geico.com

Greater New York Group (may not accept all applicants)

  • Greater New York Mutual Insurance Company
  • Insurance Company of Greater New York
732-238-6300

Agent
www.gny.com

Hanover Insurance Group

  • Hanover Insurance Company
  • Hanover New Jersey Insurance Company
 1-800-257-5720

Agent
www.hanover.com
Hartford Group
  • Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company
    (membership company for AARP)
    •      		1-800-771-8557
    1-800-423-6789    		 Direct
    www.thehartford.com

    High Point Group

    • High Point Property and Casualty Insurance Company
    • High Point Safety and Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
    • High Point Preferred Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)




    • Teachers Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
      (membership company for employees of educational institutions) (formerly Lancer Casualty Company)

    1-866-INSURANCE












    1-866-658-3224

    Agent
    www.highpointins.com

     

     

     


    Direct
    www.nj-teachers.com

    IDS Property Casualty Insurance Company

    		1-800-535-2001
    (Customer Service)    		 Direct
    www.ameriprise.com
    IFA Insurance Company 732-815-1201

    Agent
    www.ifaauto.com

    Liberty Mutual Group
    • Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company
    • Liberty Insurance Corporation
    • Liberty Mutual Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company
    		 1-888-889-9572

    Agent
    www.libertymutual.com
    Mercury Indemnity Company of America 1-877-533-6330 Agent
    www.mercuryinsurance.com
    Metropolitan Group
    • Metropolitan Group P&C Insurance Company
    • Metropolitan Direct P&C Insurance Company

    1-800-438-6381

    Direct (Metropolitan Group)
    Agent (Metropolitan Direct)
    www.metlife.com
    National General Insurance Company
    (GMAC Group; membership company for certain affinity groups)    		 1-800-847-2886

    Direct

    New Jersey Manufacturers Group
    • NJ Manufacturers Insurance Co. (membership company for certain affinity groups)
    • NJ Re-Insurance Company
    • NJ Indemnity Insurance Company (for assigned risk business only)
    		609-883-1300
    1-800-232-6600

    Direct
    www.njm.com

    New Jersey Skylands Group

    • New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association
    • New Jersey Skylands Insurance Company
    		 1-866-279-7688 Agent
    www.njsi.com
    Palisades Group
    • Palisades Safety & Insurance Association
    • Palisades Insurance Company
    • Twin Lights Insurance Company
    		1-800-725-6423



    908-219-5050
    (Twin Lights)     		Agent
    www.palisades.com



    www.twinlightsins.com

    Personal Service Insurance Company

    		 1-800-954-2442 Agent
    www.personalserviceinsurance.com
    Proformance Insurance Company 732-665-1100

    Agent
    www.proinsureco.com

    Progressive Group

    • Progressive Freedom Insurance Company
    • Progressive Garden State Insurance Company
    • Drive New Jersey Insurance Company
    		 1-800-PROGRESSIVE

    Direct (Progressive Freedom & Progressive Garden State)
    Agent (Drive New Jersey)
    www.progressive.com

    Selective Group

    • Selective Insurance Company of America
    • Selective Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
    		973-948-3000
    1-800-777-9656

    Agent
    www.selective.com

    State Farm Group

    • State Farm Guaranty Insurance Company
    • State Farm Indemnity Company
    		1-800-624-1815

    Agent
    www.statefarm.com
    Tokio Marine & Fire Insurance Company (membership company for Japanese nationals) 212-297-6600

    Agent
    www.tokiomarine.us

    Travelers of New Jersey

    • Travelers Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
    • First Trenton Indemnity Company (not accepting any new business)
    		1-877-TRAVNJ1

    Agent
    www.travelersnj.com
    21st Century Insurance Company 1-800-487-4500 Direct
    www.21st.com
    Unitrin Direct Insurance Company 1-800-253-7744

    Direct
    www.unitrindirect.com
    USAA Group (membership group for military personnel)
    • USAA Casualty Insurance Company
    • United Services Auto Association
    		 1-800-531-8080

    Direct
    www.usaa.com
    Direct Writer: The industry term for a company that uses its own sales employees to write its policies.

    To find an agent in your area,     check your telephone book or call the insurance company and ask for agents near you.
    top of page
     
    NJ Personal Automobile Insurance Plan (assigned risk market) 
    Find a PAIP Producer in Your Area
    		1-800-652-2471

    top of page
    LAD (Limited Assignment Distributors for PAIP business)
    Camden Fire Insurance Association (formerly AutoOne) 631-547-2000
    Praetorian Insurance Company (formerly Clarendon National) 201-368-8055
    AIG Centennial Insurance Company (formerly New Hampshire) 302-252-2302
    Lincoln General Insurance Company 847-700-8604

    top of page

    Motorcycle Insurers
    Aegis Security Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 3153
    Harrisburg, PA 17105-3153    		 1-800-233-2160

    Agent
    www.aegisfirst.com
    Allstate New Jersey Property & Casualty Insurance Company 1-866-222-4586

    Agent
    www.allstate.com

    American Family Home Insurance Company
    (American Modern Insurance Group)

    		 1-800-759-9008

    Agent
    www.amig.com
    Drive New Jersey Insurance Company 1-800-PROGRESSIVE Agent
    www.progressive.com
    Foremost Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 2450
    Grand Rapids, MI 49501-2450

    1-800-527-3905

    Agent
    www.foremost.com

    Foremost Property & Casualty Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 2450
    Grand Rapids, MI 49501 - 2450
    1-800-752-2461

    Direct

    www.aarpforemost.com
    GEICO Indemnity Company
    One GEICO Plaza
    Washington, DC 20076

    1-800-44-CYCLE

    Direct
    www.geico.com

    Liberty Mutual Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company 1-888-889-9572 Agent
    www.libertymutual.com
    Pacific Specialty Insurance Company 1-800-303-5000

    Direct and Agent
    www.psic-onespot.com
    Progressive Freedom Insurance Company 1-800-PROGRESSIVE Direct
    www.progressive.com
    Rider Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 3141
    Union, NJ 07083

    1-800-595-6393

    Agent
    www.ridewithrider.com

    top of page

    Specialty Insurers
    (Write one or more of the following lines of business: Antique Auto, Collectors Auto, Motorhome and Travel Trailer insurance)
    American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida
    11222 Quail Roost Drive
    Miami, FL 33157-6596

    1-800-360-2277

    Agent
    www.americancollectorsins.com
    Essentia Insurance Company 1-800-922-4050

    Agent
    www.hagerty.com
    American Modern Home Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 5323
    Cincinnati, OH 45201-5323

    1-800-543-2644

    Agent
    www.amig.com

    American Reliable Insurance Company
    11222 Quail Roost Drive
    Miami, FL 33157-6596

    1-800-360-2277

    Agent
    www.americancollectorsins.com

    Atlantic Employers Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 41484
    Philadelphia, PA 19101-1484

    215-640-1000

    Agent
    Companion Property & Casualty Insurance Company
    51 Clemson Road
    Columbia, SC 29229    		 1-877-758-3700 Agent

    Encompass Insurance Company of NJ
    3075 Sanders Road, Suite G2H
    Northbrook, IL 60062-7127

    1-800-262-5238

    Agent
    www.encompassinsurance.com

    Foremost Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 2450
    Grand Rapids, MI 49501-2450

    1-800-527-3905

    Agent
    www.foremost.com

    Metropolitan P&C Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 350
    Warwick, RI 02887-0350

    1-800-257-9496

    Agent
    www.condonskelly.com
    National Interstate Insurance Company of Hawaii
    3250 Interstate Drive
    Richfield, OH 44286

    1-330-659-8900

    Agent
    www.nationalinterstate.com

    NJ Skylands Insurance Association
    131 Morristown Road
    Basking Ridge, NJ 07920

    1-866-279-7688

    Agent
    www.njsi.com
    Philadelphia Indemnity 610-617-7900 Agent
    www.phly.com

    Progressive Garden State Insurance Company
    Drive New Jersey Insurance Company

    		 1-800-PROGRESSIVE Direct (Progressive Garden State)
    Agent (Drive New Jersey)
    www.progressive.com

    top of page
    Report changes/errors here
    Updated April. 2008
    OPRA
    		 OPRA is a state law that was enacted to give the public greater access to government records maintained by public agencies in New Jersey.
    line
    Adobe Acrobat
    		 You will need to download the latest version of Adobe Acrobat Reader in order to correctly view and print PDF (Portable Document Format) files from this web site.
    state seal
    Copyright © 2007, State of New Jersey
    New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance