In Scoring, consider the grid
of written
language |
Inadequate Command |
Limited Command |
Partial Command |
Adequate Command |
Strong Command |
Superior Command |
| Score |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
Content & Organiza-
tion
(see below) |
May lack opening and/or closing |
May lack opening and/or closing |
May lack opening and/or closing |
Generally has opening and/or closing |
Opening and closing |
Opening and closing |
| . |
Minimal response to topic; uncertain focus |
Attempts to focus
May drift or shift focus |
Usually has single focus |
Single focus |
Single focus
Sense of unity and coherence
Key ideas developed |
Single, distinct focus
Unified and coherent
Well-developed |
| . |
No planning evident; disorganized |
Attempts organization
Few, if any, transitions between ideas |
Some lapses or flaws in organization
May lack some transitions between ideas |
Ideas loosely connected
Transition evident |
Logical progression of ideas
Moderately fluent
Attempts compositional risks |
Logical progression of ideas
Fluent, cohesive
Composi-
tional risks successful |
| . |
Details random, inappropriate, or barely apparent |
Details lack elaboration, i.e., highlight paper |
Repetitious details
Several unelaborated details |
Uneven development of details |
Details appropriate and varied |
Details effective, vivid, explicit, and/or pertinent |
Usage
(see below) |
No apparent control
Severe/
numerous errors |
Numerous errors |
Errors/ patterns of errors may be evident |
Some errors that do not interfere with meaning |
Few errors |
Very few, if any, errors |
Sentence Construc-
tion
(see below) |
Assortment of incomplete and/or incorrect sentences |
Excessive monotony/ same structure
Numerous errors |
Little variety in syntax
Some errors |
Some errors that do not interfere with meaning |
Few errors |
Very few, if any, errors |
Mechanics
(see below) |
Errors so severe they detract from meaning |
Numerous serious errors |
Patterns of errors evident |
No consistent pattern of errors
Some errors that do not interfere with meaning |
Few errors |
Very few, if any, errors |