State of New Jersey Department of Education

Instruction for Competency-based Assessment

With the increased emphasis on ensuring student competency via statewide assessments, there is now a need for more attention to focus on the need for thinking in the instruction and learning process. Students needs guidance and strategies. Here are some ideas:

Teaching Thinking Skills (1991) by Kathleen Cotton is a well-researched article. Two points of several in her summary are as follows:

  • Instruction in thinking skills promotes intellectual growth and fosters academic achievement gains.
  • Instructional approaches found to promote thinking skill development include redirection, probing, and reinforcement; asking higher-order questions during classroom discussions; and lengthening wait-time during classroom questioning.

How Can We Teach Critical Thinking? a research review article by Kathryn S. Carr (1990). Major points in the article are that teachers should encourage:

1. Critical Reading - learning to evaluate, draw inferences and arrive at conclusions based on the evidence. Carr's suggestions are:

  • News media in the class
    • Differing accounts and editorials can be compared as a way of helping students read with a questioning attitude.
    • Students can construct their own arguments for discussion or publication
  • Use children's literature - to consider ideas, values, and ethical questions.

2. Writing to Learn - thinking through writing. Suggestions from the literature:

  • For first-order thinking: free writing -- unplanned and free-association in order to produce conceptual insights.
  • For second-order thinking -- examination of inferences and prejudices and capturing logic and control

3. Classification Games - these play a significant role in the development of logical thinking and abstract concepts from early childhood to adulthood. Classification skill is integral to vocabulary-concept development and, therefore, to reading and retention of information.Ideas suggested:

  • Sorting of concrete objects for the young child or verbal analogies for a any age;
  • Integration of classification activities into content areas is crucial to their value; and
  • Brainstorming techniques relating old to new knowledge

Conclusion: Every teacher should create an atmosphere where students are encouraged to read deeply, question, engage in divergent thinking, look for relationships among ideas, and grapple with real-life issues.

Inquire Further

Power Learning: Creating Student-Centered Problems-Based Classrooms: Gives problem-based activities to emphasize questioning and thinking for several content areas.

Filling the Tool Box: Classroom Strategies to Engender Student Questioning. Part One gives questioning strategies in class involving students and for homework.

More for the Teacher

Higher-order thinking (from Australia). See also menu items on left.

The Partnership for 21st Century Skills

Strategies for Teaching Critical Thinking. A research-based article that gives skills and three strategies:
1. Building categories
2. Finding problems
3. Enhancing the classroom environment.

Test Yourself on thinking levels! Now, using a worksheet, make up one question at a low level, then change the question to a higher, and then a higher level.