- In this story, people do not always express what they
are really thinking or feeling. Although he smiles during
C Band practice, Mr. Helmholtz continues to "brood
inwardly."
Identify what this phrase means. Explain how this habit
affects events later in the story.
Provide specific information from the story to support
your response.
- We read that, when Mr. Helmholtz considers that Plummer
has been in C Band for three years, he feels a mixture of
"pity and fear." It is unusual to pity and fear
a person at the same time.
Identify why Mr. Helmholtz pities Plummer. Explain what
his fear of Plummer reveals about his own personality.
Provide specific information from the story to support
your response.
- Near the end of this story, Plummer tells Mr. Helmholtz,
"I'm growing up, and you're not."
Identify what Plummer means by this statement. Explain
how this statement helps you to understand the theme of
the story.
Provide specific information from the story to support
your response.
Materials/Resources:
- Access to a word processor or computer, if desired.
- Tape recorder or camcorder if student makes an oral presentation.
Techniques for PAT Scoring:
See Reading
Item-Specific Rubric for this PAT.
|