New Jersey State Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners
Public Session Minutes
February 27, 2002
A. CALL TO ORDER
This scheduled meeting of the Board was called to order at 9:55 a.m. in the Somerset Conference Room, 6th floor, 124 Halsey Street, Newark, New Jersey.
B. ROLL CALL
The following Board Members were present for this meeting:
Board Vice President Neal L. Beeber, DVM
Absent: Board President John G. De Vries, DVM
Staff present: Executive Director Diane I. Romano
Public present: Dr. Christopher P. Laffoon, NJVMA
A quorum was present for the entire meeting.
The meeting was presided over by Dr. Beeber.
In accordance with Chapter 231 of P.L. 1975, more commonly referred to as the Sunshine Law, adequate notice of this meeting was provided by mailing to the Office of the Secretary of State, the Star Ledger, the Trenton Times, the Bergen Record and the Courier Post.
C. APPROVAL OF PUBLIC MINUTES
On a motion of Dr. Meirs, seconded by Dr. Logan and unanimous vote of the Board, the January 23, 2002 public session Minutes were approved as submitted.
Mrs. Romano reported that the following bills have been introduced/reintroduced in the 2002 Session and are in committee:
A-547 ' revised practice act
The following bill is on second reading in the Assembly:
A656/S-349 ' allows veterinary students to take licensing exam in senior year
The following bill passed the Assembly and is in Senate committee:
A-354 ' prohibits veterinarians from restricting pet owners' choice of specialist
The Division requested the Board's comments on S-970, a proposed bill requiring criminal history record background checks for health care professionals (including veterinarians) as a condition of initial licensure. The Board determined to take no position on this bill.
1. Letter from Ingamar R. Caliolio, DVM
On a motion of Dr. Meirs, seconded by Dr. Self and unanimous vote, the Board determined to deny this candidate's request for a waiver of the ten-year rule for acceptance of national exam scores since the Board has no discretionary authority to waive provisions of the statute.
2. Lorie Ann Valentino, DVM, MS, DACVIM
On a motion of Dr. Self, seconded b Dr. Meirs and unanimous vote, the Board approved this candidate to sit for the jurisprudence exam pending our receipt of a clean disciplinary history from the State of Missouri.
3. Carole Marie Starita, DVM
On a motion of Dr. Self, seconded by Mr. Scerni and unanimous vote, the Board approved this candidate to sit for the jurisprudence exam.
4. Paul Charles Gambardella, VMD
On a motion of Mr. Scerni, seconded by Dr. Self and unanimous vote, the Board approved this candidate to sit for the jurisprudence exam.
5. David Samuels, VMD
On a motion of Dr. Meirs, seconded by Mr. Scerni and unanimous vote, the Board denied this candidate since he does not meet the requirement of practical clinical experience for three of the last five years.
Regulatory Analyst Charles Manning appeared before the Board to work with the members regarding their request for two new regulations.
1. The Board discussed the proposed regulation concerning delegation of authority and responsibility. Mr. Manning will draft a proposed regulation for the Board's approval.
2. The Board discussed a proposed regulation defining what is a "prescription". Subsequent to discussion, the Board determined that a new regulation is not required and rescinded its request for same.
H. NAVLE RESULTS
Mrs. Romano reported that 17 candidates took the November/December 2001 NAVLE from New Jersey. Seven candidates passed (41%); ten failed (59%). High score was 86; low score was 52. The Board directed Mrs. Romano to do a summary report listing candidates' names, the schools they attended and their pass/fail grades.
1. Dr. Paul Nolan
Mrs. Romano reported that Dr. Paul Nolan felt it was his responsibility to inform the Board that the Illinois veterinary board also disciplined him, based on New Jersey's action.
2. Dr. Thomas M. Jacks
The Board directed Mrs. Romano to order a service plaque for Dr. Tom Jacks for his many years of service as a Board member.
3. AAVSB Annual Meeting
Dr. Neal Beeber will attend this meeting on July 13-16 in Nashville representing the Board.
J. DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS
1. File #01-076 ' Donald Kentner, DVM
Dr. Kentner paid a $500 civil penalty for prescription drug violations and one act of negligence. This file is now closed.
2. I/M/O Forrest Gerry III, VMD
Dr. Gerry paid a $2,500 civil penalty for failure to cooperate and comply in a Board investigation. This file is now closed.
3. File #00-063 ' Edwin O. Gilbert, DVM
A Consent Order was filed encompassing (1) reprimand; (2) Dr. Gilbert shall take and pass the NBVME species specific small animal examination; (3) Dr. Gilbert shall successfully attend and complete 10 hours of modern anesthesia techniques; $5,000 fine; and $2,859.45 costs for violations of N.J.S.A. 45:1-21(c) gross negligence, gross malpractice or gross incompetence; and N.J.S.A. 45:1- 21(h) records keeping violations.
K. NEXT MEETING
The next regularly scheduled meeting of the Board is March 27, 2002 at 9:30 a.m. in the Somerset Conference Room, 6th floor, 124 Halsey Street, Newark, New Jersey.
L. EXECUTIVE SESSION
On a motion of Dr. Self, seconded by Dr. Logan and unanimous vote, the Board went into executive session to hold investigative inquiries and to discuss pending consumer complaints and investigations. They returned to open session to record their votes for those matters resulting in disciplinary action:
This meeting of the Board was adjourned at 3:00 p.m.