CPSBIDFM-1 DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE 1 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES/PROCUREMENT DIVISION TRENTON, NEW JERSEY TABULATION OF BIDS AND UNIT PRICES ROUTE I-280 FROM LAUREL AVENUE TO 6TH STREET PAVEMENT REPAIR CONTRACT NO. 006053070; CITY OF LIVINGSTON, ORANGE & NEWARK TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE & EAST ORANGE, COUNTY OF ESSEX FEDERAL PROJECT NO. IM-280-6(100) D.P. NO. 08101 BIDS RECEIVED APRIL 22, 2008 CONTRACT AWARD DATE JUNE 05, 2008 BIDDERS TOTAL PRICE BID 1 . DELLA PELLO PAVING INC $ 21,570,345.61 40 MILLTOWN ROAD UNION NJ07083 2 . CRISDEL GROUP, INC $ 21,927,091.78 240 RYAN ST SO PLAINFIELD NJ07080 3 . INTERCOUNTY PAVING ASSOC LLC $ 23,322,322.00 859 WILLOW GROVE STREET HACKETTSTOWN NJ07840 4 . TARHEEL ENTERPRISES INC $ 24,271,586.75 2000 HIGHWAY 35 MORGAN NJ08879 5 . TILCON NEW YORK INC $ 24,968,000.00 625 MT HOPE ROAD WHARTON NJ07885 6 . IEW CONSTR GP $ 27,786,739.05 75 SCULPTORS WAY P O 800TRENTON NJ08619 7 . JOSEPH M SANZARI INC REJECTED 90 W. FRANKLIN STREET HACKENSACK NJ07601 ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT CONTRACT LOW BIDDER 2ND LOW BIDDER NO. QUANTITY UNIT PRICE DOLLAR AMT. UNIT PRICE DOLLAR AMT. 1 PERFORMANCE BOND AND PAYMENT BOND LS 1 86,900.00 86,900.00 126,000.00 126,000.00 2 FINAL CLEANUP LS 1 38,841.00 38,841.00 14,515.46 14,515.46 3 CONSTRUCTION LAYOUT LS 1 38,000.00 38,000.00 1.00 1.00 4 FIELD OFFICE TYPE B SET-UP U 1 29,500.00 29,500.00 43,532.50 43,532.50 5 FIELD OFFICE TYPE B MAINTENANCE MO 18 4,720.00 84,960.00 3,355.00 60,390.00 6 TELEPHONE SERVICE LS 1 4,500.00 4,500.00 4,500.00 4,500.00 7 FUEL PRICE ADJUSTMENT LS 1 29,700.00 29,700.00 29,700.00 29,700.00 8 TRAINEES HRS 1,300 2.00 2,600.00 1.00 1,300.00 9 OWNER'S AND CONTRACTOR'S PROTECTIVE LS 1 41,000.00 41,000.00 52,250.00 52,250.00 LIABILITY INSURANCE 10 PROGRESS SCHEDULE LS 1 26,100.00 26,100.00 23,210.00 23,210.00 11 MOBILIZATION LS 1 1,662,000.00 1,662,000.00 2,737,014.76 2,737,014.76 12 DENSE-GRADED AGGREGATE BASE COURSE, 6" THICK SY 50 120.00 6,000.00 39.49 1,974.50 13 ROADWAY EXCAVATION, ROCK CY 20 50.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 20,000.00 14 COARSE AGGREGATE, SIZE NO. 57 CY 220 59.00 12,980.00 92.98 20,455.60 15 CLEARING SITE LS 1 23,540.00 23,540.00 47,826.09 47,826.09 16 ROADWAY EXCAVATION, UNCLASSIFIED CY 150 88.50 13,275.00 167.99 25,198.50 17 SAWCUTTING LF 3,806 1.00 3,806.00 3.03 11,532.18 18 MILLING CONCRETE PAVEMENT, 3/4" VARIABLE SY 151,615 3.32 503,361.80 2.83 429,070.45 DEPTH 19 MILLING, 2" VARIABLE DEPTH SY 181,151 2.25 407,589.75 3.31 599,609.81 20 EARTH EXCAVATION FOR TEST PITS CY 20 120.00 2,400.00 301.83 6,036.60 21 SILT FENCE LF 300 12.00 3,600.00 4.23 1,269.00 22 INLET FILTERS U 593 83.00 49,219.00 31.24 18,525.32 23 HAYBALES U 50 47.00 2,350.00 30.62 1,531.00 24 CONCRETE WASHOUT FACILITY LS 1 2,945.00 2,945.00 6,875.00 6,875.00 25 OIL ONLY EMERGENCY SPILL KIT U 2 590.00 1,180.00 1,210.00 2,420.00 26 GEOTEXTILE SY 600 5.00 3,000.00 1.28 768.00 27 SUBBASE CY 56 88.30 4,944.80 149.85 8,391.60 28 SELECTIVE CLEARING SY 4,500 5.00 22,500.00 4.03 18,135.00 29 BITUMINOUS CONCRETE PATCH T 120 88.30 10,596.00 218.21 26,185.20 30 ASPHALT PRICE ADJUSTMENT LS 1 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 31 TACK COAT 64-22 GAL 100,000 3.65 365,000.00 3.25 325,000.00 32 POLYMERIZED JOINT ADHESIVE LF 106,895 .50 53,447.50 .41 43,826.95 33 CORE SAMPLES, HOT MIX ASPHALT U 100 88.30 8,830.00 103.92 10,392.00 34 SUPERPAVE HOT MIX ASPHALT 12.5H76 SURFACE T 11,010 84.00 924,840.00 90.94 1,001,249.40 COURSE 35 SUPERPAVE HOT MIX ASPHALT 12.5H76 T 6,204 78.85 489,185.40 80.64 500,290.56 INTERMEDIATE COURSE 36 HIGH PERFORMANCE THIN OVERLAY T 20,000 111.80 2,236,000.00 115.22 2,304,400.00 37 CLEANING AND SEALING OF EXISTING CRACKS AND LF 275,118 2.50 687,795.00 3.03 833,607.54 JOINTS IN CONCRETE SURFACE COURSE 38 SLAB STABILIZATION, POLYURETHANE GROUT LBS 350,004 4.30 1,505,017.20 3.99 1,396,515.96 39 PARTIAL DEPTH CONCRETE PAVEMENT REPAIR SF 10,064 41.20 414,636.80 42.44 427,116.16 40 FULL DEPTH REINFORCED CONCRETE PAVEMENT REPAI SF 35,237 73.00 2,572,301.00 57.34 2,020,489.58 PRECAST SYSTEM 41 SLAB STABILIZATION, DEFLECTION TESTING U 5,000 19.10 95,500.00 17.79 88,950.00 42 ASPHALT-RUBBER OPEN-GRADED FRICTION COURSE T 28,840 115.35 3,326,694.00 121.07 3,491,658.80 43 6" HIGH DENSITY POLYETHYLENE PERFORATED PIPE LF 24 25.40 609.60 29.36 704.64 44 8" HIGH DENSITY POLYETHYLENE PERFORATED PIPE LF 268 29.45 7,892.60 28.54 7,648.72 45 12" HIGH DENSITY POLYETHYLENE PERFORATED PIPE LF 200 41.20 8,240.00 31.96 6,392.00 46 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SURFACE COURSE T 5,820 186.20 1,083,684.00 179.09 1,042,303.80 47 EDGE DRAIN LF 9,200 24.15 222,180.00 26.48 243,616.00 48 15" REINFORCED CONCRETE CULVERT PIPE, LF 15 295.00 4,425.00 181.66 2,724.90 CLASS II 49 BICYCLE SAFE GRATES U 578 236.00 136,408.00 228.64 132,153.92 50 9" X 18" CONCRETE VERTICAL CURB LF 200 82.40 16,480.00 89.49 17,898.00 51 SNOW FENCE, PLASTIC LF 500 5.90 2,950.00 3.49 1,745.00 52 TEMPORARY PAVEMENT MARKERS U 37,730 3.00 113,190.00 1.32 49,803.60 53 BREAKAWAY BARRICADES U 50 118.00 5,900.00 145.20 7,260.00 54 DRUMS U 100 60.00 6,000.00 81.84 8,184.00 55 TRAFFIC CONES U 400 29.00 11,600.00 17.82 7,128.00 56 CONSTRUCTION IDENTIFICATION SIGNS, 6' X 12' U 2 1,415.00 2,830.00 2,356.11 4,712.22 57 VARIABLE MESSAGE SIGNS U 4 23,540.00 94,160.00 20,350.00 81,400.00 58 CONSTRUCTION SIGNS SF 2,403 11.75 28,235.25 22.53 54,139.59 59 ILLUMINATED FLASHING ARROWS, 4' X 8' U 2 5,900.00 11,800.00 6,050.00 12,100.00 60 TRAFFIC CONTROL TRUCKS WITH MOUNTED U 4 21,200.00 84,800.00 27,829.91 111,319.64 CRASH CUSHIONS 61 TRUCK-MOUNTED CRASH CUSHION REPLACEMENT U 2 5,900.00 11,800.00 11,784.61 23,569.22 CARTRIDGE 62 TRAFFIC STRIPES, LONG LIFE, EPOXY RESIN, 6 LF 310,571 .46 142,862.66 .35 108,699.85 INCHES 63 TRAFFIC MARKINGS, LINES, LONG LIFE, LF 15,063 .53 7,983.39 .57 8,585.91 THERMOPLASTIC 64 REMOVAL OF PAVEMENT REFLECTORS AND CASTINGS U 1,000 7.10 7,100.00 7.46 7,460.00 65 TWO-WAY PLOWABLE MONO-DIRECTIONAL U 3,590 31.80 114,162.00 23.76 85,298.40 WHITE PAVEMENT RELECTORS AND CASTINGS 66 TWO-WAY PLOWABLE MONO-DIRECTIONAL U 1,103 31.80 35,075.40 23.76 26,207.28 AMBER PAVEMENT RELECTORS AND CASTINGS 67 RUMBLE STRIP LF 128,373 .42 53,916.66 .38 48,781.74 68 METER CABINETS, TYPE T U 1 2,160.00 2,160.00 1,650.00 1,650.00 69 3" RIGID METALLIC CONDUIT, TYPE CUR LF 270 74.45 20,101.50 93.50 25,245.00 70 3" RIGID METALLIC CONDUIT, TYPE CUG LF 50 43.85 2,192.50 49.50 2,475.00 71 FOUNDATIONS, TYPE MCF U 1 1,250.00 1,250.00 990.00 990.00 72 38" JUNCTION BOXES U 29 3,540.00 102,660.00 3,190.00 92,510.00 73 6" RIGID METALLIC CONDUIT, TYPE CDD LF 933 315.00 293,895.00 319.00 297,627.00 74 THREE 1.25" HDPE CONCUIT, TYPE BC LF 12,190 31.20 380,328.00 14.30 174,317.00 75 REMOVAL OF 17" X 30" JB U 4 45.00 180.00 825.00 3,300.00 76 THREE 1.25" HDPE CONDUIT, TYPE BS LF 8,853 31.20 276,213.60 20.35 180,158.55 77 THREE 1.25" HDPE CONDUIT, TYPE CB LF 30 44.75 1,342.50 25.30 759.00 78 ROADWAY JUNCTION BOX U 2 5,270.00 10,540.00 6,820.00 13,640.00 79 FIBER OPTIC CABLE, TYPE A LF 42,805 3.90 166,939.50 4.95 211,884.75 80 FIBER OPTIC CABLE, TYPE D LF 707 12.95 9,155.65 3.30 2,333.10 81 TTS DETECTOR, TYPE A U 5 7,080.00 35,400.00 4,840.00 24,200.00 82 CONTROLLER, TTS U 1 56,420.00 56,420.00 34,650.00 34,650.00 83 18" X 36" JUNCTION BOXES U 22 1,950.00 42,900.00 1,760.00 38,720.00 84 2" RIGID METALLIC CONDUIT, TYPE CUG LF 4,327 32.10 138,896.70 28.60 123,752.20 85 2" RIGID METALLIC CONDUIT, TYPE CS LF 135 35.30 4,765.50 36.30 4,900.50 86 FOUNDATIONS, TYPE 1M-MC U 1 2,650.00 2,650.00 2,640.00 2,640.00 87 MULTIPLE LIGHTING WIRE, NO. 8 AWG LF 3,993 3.35 13,376.55 2.53 10,102.29 88 MULTIPLE LIGHTING WIRE, NO. 6 AWG LF 952 3.65 3,474.80 2.75 2,618.00 89 MULTIPLE LIGHTING WIRE, NO. 2 AWG LF 7,930 4.95 39,253.50 4.07 32,275.10 90 FOUNDATIONS, TYPE P U 1 1,810.00 1,810.00 880.00 880.00 91 TRANSFORMER U 1 4,045.00 4,045.00 2,090.00 2,090.00 92 DMS SIGN INSTALL U 1 4,600.00 4,600.00 23,760.00 23,760.00 93 DMS STANDARD, TYPE A U 1 326,855.00 326,855.00 171,313.80 171,313.80 94 SERVICE WIRE, NO. 6 AWG LF 225 3.65 821.25 2.75 618.75 95 2" RIGID METALLIC CONDUIT, TYPE CUR LF 127 70.65 8,972.55 41.80 5,308.60 96 CCTV CAMERA STANDARD, TYPE 75 U 1 40,785.00 40,785.00 45,980.00 45,980.00 97 CCTV CAMERA CONTROLLER, TYPE 75 U 1 38,250.00 38,250.00 24,310.00 24,310.00 98 FOUNDATION, TYPE CCTV U 1 3,900.00 3,900.00 6,050.00 6,050.00 99 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 100 FOUNDATIONS, TYPE 1M U 1 1,700.00 1,700.00 1,540.00 1,540.00 101 CONTROL CENTER SYSTEM LS 1 22,305.00 22,305.00 53,185.00 53,185.00 102 LOOP DETECTOR LF 900 15.00 13,500.00 19.80 17,820.00 103 CLEANING EXISTING DRAINAGE STRUCTURES U 60 148.00 8,880.00 137.50 8,250.00 104 CLEAN EXISTING PIPE, 12" TO 24" DIAMETER LF 5,400 4.65 25,110.00 4.35 23,490.00 105 CLEAN EXISTING PIPE, OVER 24" TO 48" DIAMETER LF 2,300 5.90 13,570.00 5.45 12,535.00 106 RESET CASTINGS U 5 1,060.00 5,300.00 710.12 3,550.60 107 RECONSTRUCTED INLETS, TYPE B, USING EXISTING U 2 2,720.00 5,440.00 1,841.04 3,682.08 CASTING 108 MILLING, 4" VARIABLE DEPTH SY 3,239 6.50 21,053.50 7.69 24,907.91 109 TURF REPAIR STRIP LF 300 12.00 3,600.00 15.43 4,629.00 110 BORROW TOPSOIL CY 50 77.00 3,850.00 111.29 5,564.50 111 CONCRETE BARRIER CURB REPAIR LS 1 3,000.00 3,000.00 7,286.22 7,286.22 112 SERVICE WIRE, NO. 1/0 AWG LF 7,070 5.85 41,359.50 8.25 58,327.50 113 METER CABINET, TYPE 1M-ML-480 U 1 18,300.00 18,300.00 13,805.00 13,805.00 114 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 115 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 116 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 117 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 118 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 119 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 ROUTE I-280 E.B. OVER PLEASENT VALLEY WAY 120 CLEARING SITE, BRIDGE LS 1 4,710.00 4,710.00 956.52 956.52 121 REPAIR OF CONCRETE DECK, TYPE B SF 1,400 52.70 73,780.00 46.70 65,380.00 122 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SURFACE COURSE TON 97 186.00 18,042.00 179.09 17,371.73 123 ASPHALTIC BRIDGE JOINT SYSTEM LF 160 140.10 22,416.00 172.65 27,624.00 124 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 125 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 126 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 127 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 128 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 129 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SURFACE COURSE TON 97 186.00 18,042.00 179.09 17,371.73 130 ASPHALTIC BRIDGE JOINT SYSTEM LF 160 140.10 22,416.00 172.65 27,624.00 131 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 132 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 133 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 134 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 ROUTE I-280 W.B. OVER PLEASENT VALLEY WAY 135 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 136 CLEARING SITE, BRIDGE LS 1 4,710.00 4,710.00 956.52 956.52 137 REPAIR OF CONCRETE DECK, TYPE B SF 1,400 52.70 73,780.00 46.70 65,380.00 138 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SURFACE COURSE TON 88 186.00 16,368.00 179.09 15,759.92 139 ASPHALTIC BRIDGE JOINT SYSTEM LF 422 140.10 59,122.20 183.50 77,437.00 140 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 141 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 142 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 143 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 ROUTE I-280 E.B. & W.B. OVER RAMP "A" 144 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 145 CLEARING SITE, BRIDGE LS 1 4,710.00 4,710.00 3,826.09 3,826.09 146 REMOVAL OF HOT MIX ASPHALT OVERLAY SY 5,833 5.30 30,914.90 4.44 25,898.52 147 REPAIR OF CONCRETE DECK, TYPE B SF 5,214 52.70 274,777.80 46.70 243,493.80 148 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SURFACE COURSE TON 645 186.00 119,970.00 179.09 115,513.05 149 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 150 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 151 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 152 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 ROUTE I-280 E.B. OVER RT. 75 LOCAL STRRETS NJTRR 153 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 154 CLEARING SITE, BRIDGE LS 1 4,710.00 4,710.00 2,869.56 2,869.56 155 REMOVAL OF HOT MIX ASPHALT OVERLAY SY 5,260 5.30 27,878.00 4.44 23,354.40 156 REPAIR OF CONCRETE DECK, TYPE B SF 4,734 52.70 249,481.80 46.70 221,077.80 157 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SYSTEM TON 575 186.00 106,950.00 179.09 102,976.75 158 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 159 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 160 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 161 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 ROUTE I-280 W.B. OVER RT. 75 LOCAL STREETS NJTRR 162 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 163 CLEARING SITE, BRIDGE LS 1 4,710.00 4,710.00 1,913.04 1,913.04 164 REMOVAL OF HOT MIX ASPHALT OVERLAY SY 500 5.30 2,650.00 4.44 2,220.00 165 REPAIR OF CONCRETE DECK, TYPE B SF 1,650 52.70 86,955.00 46.70 77,055.00 166 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 167 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 168 BRIDGE DECK WATERPROOF SYSTEM TON 55 186.00 10,230.00 179.09 9,849.95 169 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 170 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 ROUTE I-280 OVER MARTIN LUTHER KING BLVD. 171 NO ITEM U 0 .00 0.00 .00 0.00 SUMMARY OF AMOUNTS ROAD ITEMS $ 20,333,021.91 $ 20,781,182.40 BRIDGE ITEMS $ 1,237,323.70 $ 1,145,909.38 SUB-TOTAL AMOUNTS FOR BRIDGE WORK ROUTE I-280 E.B. OVER PLEASENT VALLEY WAY $ 159,406.00 $ 156,327.98 ROUTE I-280 W.B. OVER PLEASENT VALLEY WAY $ 153,980.20 $ 159,533.44 ROUTE I-280 E.B. & W.B. OVER RAMP "A" $ 430,372.70 $ 388,731.46 ROUTE I-280 E.B. OVER RT. 75 LOCAL STRRETS NJTRR $ 389,019.80 $ 350,278.51 ROUTE I-280 W.B. OVER RT. 75 LOCAL STREETS NJTRR $ 104,545.00 $ 91,037.99 ROUTE I-280 OVER MARTIN LUTHER KING BLVD. 0.00 0.00 AGREE AGREE (HEADER) LOW BID =$ 21,570,345.61 (HEADER) 2ND LOW BID =$ 21,927,091.78 COMPUTED LOW BID =$ 21,570,345.61 COMPUTED 2ND LOW BID =$ 21,927,091.78 COMPUTED LOW BID =$ 21,570,345.61 COMPUTED 2ND LOW BID =$ 21,927,091.78