John
E. McCormac
State Treasurer
Testimony before the
Assembly Budget Committee
May 24, 2005
Mr.
Chairman, distinguished members of the Assembly Budget Committee. Good
morning. I welcome this opportunity to return and detail to you
a revised revenue picture that has significant implications for both
the current budget and Acting Governor Codey’s budget for FY
2006.
As you know, New Jersey’s revenue picture has vastly improved
since the Governor’s budget address on March 1. On the strength
of continuing economic expansion, revenues are $1.2 billion higher
than anticipated for the two fiscal years. This growth, almost exclusively
in Gross Income Tax collections, that has been driven by sustained
job growth, low unemployment, dramatic business investment and high
wage earnings.
We’ve said time and again, and it bears repeating, that economic
investment does not happen by accident. In New Jersey, multiple agencies
work as a team to present the right incentives, build healthy relationships
and solve tough problems so that businesses can grow and prosper and
the keep state’s economy strong.
This turnaround marks a stark contrast to four years ago at this time
when revenues, which hitched a ride with the skyrocketing stock market
of the late 1990s, began a freefall that coincided with the bursting
of the stock market bubble and the loss of thousands of jobs.
Governor Codey is acutely aware of how New Jersey’s fortunes
can quickly swing from one direction to another, which is why he said
in his budget address that “the days of spending like there is
no tomorrow end today.” His message has been clear and consistent:
While the good news is that New Jersey’s revenue picture has
brightened, storm clouds in the form of growing mandatory expenses
and pressing priorities can move in without warning and rain on New
Jersey’s budget parade.
The Governor therefore has proposed that we take a measured approach
to our windfall and to put the taxpayer first. With this additional
revenue, he would like to accomplish three things: restore property
tax relief, eliminate tax increases and boost the budget surplus.
We propose first to reserve several hundred million dollars for property
tax relief. The Property tax relief is a top priority and now that
additional funding is possible, this need must be met. We are also
prepared to work with the Legislature on setting aside revenues from
our improved fiscal picture on other priorities in the areas of public
education and health care.
The Governor made some agonizing choices on increasing taxes when
he proposed an austere budget in March. He made the decisions because
the revenue to support key initiative did not exist. We are pleased
that several of these increases can now be eliminated due to growth
of revenue from existing sources.
Finally, Governor Codey proposes to place a significant part of the
additional revenue in surplus to shore up State finances and put New
Jersey on more solid fiscal footing. Building the surplus is like making
a down payment on future fiscal stability. The structural problems
and mandatory cost increases we face every year aren’t going
away and New Jersey must act now, when it can, to prepare for the next
economic downturn. A bigger surplus also sends the right signal to
Wall Street on Governor Codey’s approach to fiscal responsibility.
FY 2005 -- Revenues
New Jersey’s revenues for FY 2005 are projected to end the year
approximately $665 million ahead of March 1 projections. Most of this
increase -- $525 million – is directly attributable to the spring
collection performance of the Gross Income Tax. We now project the
Gross Income Tax to finish the year at $9.58 billion.
During this period we also saw higher than anticipated revenue from
the Corporation Business Tax. The March 1 projection for the CBT was
$2.16 billion. We’re revising this revenue to finish FY 2005
at $2.2 billion. We are guardedly optimistic about this finish because
last June, the CBT’s monthly collection numbers dropped unexpectedly
and we missed our year end target for FY 2004.
While we’ve seen better-than-expected performance from these
two revenues, the same cannot be said of the State Sales Tax. Under
the budget adopted for FY 2005, the Sales Tax was projected to generate
$6.6 billion. That target was reduced to $6.52 billion in March, and
has been adjusted again to finish the year at $6.51 billion.
Among the other revenues, FY 2005 is generating better than expected
growth in the Corporation Tax paid by banks and other financial institutions,
up by $30 million in FY 2005, to an end-of-year projection of $115
million. The Realty Transfer fee, meanwhile, is exceeding estimates
by $20 million for FY 2005, and is trending higher for FY 06 as well.
Last year at this time, total income for FY 2004 exceeded targets
by $511 million. The increased revenue made it possible to build up
the budget surplus and meet end of the year supplemental spending requirements.
This year, FY 2005 revenues will also be higher than anticipated.
Governor Codey proposes to move all $665 million into the surplus until
final agreements are reached with the Legislature on restoring property
tax relief programs that are funded out of the FY 2006 budget. The
transfer raises the surplus for FY 2005 from $400 million to $1 billion.
I would like to now address revenues for FY 2006.
FY 2006 – The Income Tax
As the fiscal backbone of New Jersey’s budget, the Gross Income
is projected to continue its growth trend for FY 2006. Based on spring
collections, we have revised our GIT estimate for FY 2006 from $9.52
billion to $10 billion, a $480 million differential. Again, the GIT
accounts for the vast majority of the revised revenue increase of $600
million for the next fiscal year.
FY 2006 – The Sales Tax
The New Jersey Sales Tax is anticipated to generate $7.14 billion
in FY 2006, which is $30 million below our March estimate of $7.17
billion. As you know, this figure anticipates approximately $275 million
in new extensions as part of an effort to modernize the structure and
reach of the sales tax. Taking into account the improving revenue picture,
Governor Codey is proposing that the extension revenue target of $275
million be cut by $100 million, which will bring the sales tax collection
below the $7.14 billion total for 2006 and reduce the number of services
to which the sales tax would be extended under the modernization and
fairness initiative.
FY 2006 – The Corporation Business Tax
The performance of the Corporation Business Tax will stay strong for
FY 2006, but it remains one of the more difficult major revenue sources
to predict. After a strong 11 months last fiscal year, collections
dropped below expectations in June to close out the year. We won’t
be surprised by a “June surprise” this year, and we are
cautious about our predictions for 2006. We anticipate $2.18 billion
in CBT revenues for FY 06, which is $56 million over the revised number
for 2005.
Asset Sales
Under the budget proposed to you in March, the amount of spending
supported by one-time revenue raisers was down dramatically - 70 percent – from
FY 2004. We propose at this time to reduce non-recurring revenues further
by cutting the target for selling State assets, from $500 million to
$200 million. This means that the reduction on one-time revenues will
be closer to 80 percent from FY 2005 to FY 2006.
Although we have initiated a concentrated effort to meet the FY 2006
target of $500 million, the task is extremely ambitious and complex.
As we inventory and investigate properties that, at first blush appear
to be ripe for a sale, we often encounter stumbling blocks leave us
little choice but to remove the property from consideration.
Many properties that we originally considered were passed over after
information surfaced about deed restrictions, restrictions on the use
of the proceeds from the sale, and other factors, such as reverter
clauses, environmental concerns or development restrictions.
For example, a state-owned golf course in Wall Township at first appeared
as a logical and easy choice for an asset sale. That is, until learning
later that we would be required under state law to deposit the proceeds
of that sale into the Green Acres Program., not into the General Fund
as part of the Asset Sale line item. We encountered other properties
that were not marketable because they were surrounded by environmental
wetlands, and the list of exclusions grows larger almost with each
passing day.
Treasury’s Division of Property Management and Construction
is working closely with all State departments to meet the time constraints
and monetary goals of the asset sale, and the $200 million target is
simply more realistic for 2006.
Realty Transfer fee/Estate Tax –
As I indicated earlier, the Realty Transfer Fee is exceeding projections
for FY 2005, and we expect that trend to continue in FY 2006. We are
therefore eliminating this fee increase from the FY 2006 budget. Similarly,
we are proposing to rescind a planned increase of the Estate Tax of
$25 million because of the improved revenue picture.
To summarize, our budget is still approximately $27.4 billion, still
contains the largest spending decrease in New Jersey history and is
still about 2 percent less than the budget for FY 2005. The budget
contains $150 million less in revenue raisers, reduces one-time revenues
by about 80 percent, versus 70 percent as proposed on March 1, and
increases the State surplus to over $1 billion. Within that surplus,
we have reserved $400 million to spending down for property tax relief,
as well as to make small investments in the areas of health and education.
These changes reflect Governor Codey’s responsible approach
to managing the unanticipated revenue growth of approximately $1.2
billion as we close out FY 2005 and enter FY 2006. We are overjoyed
to have the benefit of this additional revenue, but the Governor will
not over-commit the resources and leave a potential problem for the
budget of his successor.
------------------------
At this time I would like to proceed with presenting testimony on
the State Treasury Department budget.
As you all know, the Treasury Department plays a key role in crafting
the State of New Jersey’s budget, but the responsibilities of
the department stretch far beyond management of revenues and appropriations.
As New Jersey’s Treasurer, I have oversight of 12 divisions that
encompass a wide range of areas that include everything from investing
the State’s money wisely and managing hundreds of State properties
to procuring public contracts and serving as custodian of one of the
largest public-employee retirement systems in the country.
The Department of the Treasury has been doing more with less. The
Governor’s proposed budget allocates $379.5 million to the Department
Of Treasury, a decrease of $22.2 million, or 5.5 percent, from FY 2005.
Our workforce is down as well. Near the start of the new administration,
Treasury’s workforce stood at 3,764. Our workforce is now 3,687,
with the vast majority of net employee growth falling in our Division
of Taxation’s compliance and enforcement area.
Over this same period of time, there has been an 18.5 percent reduction
in the number of unclassified employees in the Department of the Treasury,
from 168 in 2002 to the present level of 137.
Our continuing goal is to find ways to lower our operational bottom
line while at the same time, raise the bar of performance in the delivery
of services to the public and other constituencies. In all of our divisions
we are putting mechanisms and procedures into place that reduce our
own operating costs and improve our efficiency, eliminate waste and
duplication and deliver tangible savings for New Jersey’s taxpayers.
When we look for cost cutting, we must look everywhere, including
our travel budget. Treasury’s travel expenses for FY 2005, at
just over $1 million, are 22.3 percent lower than travel expenses incurred
by the Treasury Department in FY 2001. Similarly, employee mileage
reimbursement costs are lower now than in 2001, falling from $665,884
in 2001 to the present level of $620,222.
We can do more to save and preserve the tax dollars entrusted to us,
and we will. In cooperation with the Governor’s Office, the Department
of the Treasury is developing changes to the State Travel circular
to enforce the following:
• Eliminate public transportation services between Boston and
Washington when two or more employees are traveling to the same event.
We will require employees to use a State of New Jersey vehicle or submit
for mileage reimbursement for their own vehicle.
• When one employee is traveling, NJ Transit must be used as
a mass transit option. Amtrak will be permitted only if it is the only
means of travel available. We will also eliminate the use of high speed
transit services, such as Acela.
• We will require departments to fully enforce all travel regulations
required under the State travel policy, particularly the per diem limitations.
Additionally, no reimbursements will be permitted for meals when a
registration fee that includes meals in paid.
• We will also seek to work cooperatively with the Port Authority
of New York and New Jersey to coordinate parking and transportation
services for State employees at Newark Airport in an effort to minimize
or eliminate these expenses.
Treasury is uniquely positioned to take actions which result in savings
and economies in the day to day operations of not just our department,
but government-wide.
Through the Division of Administration, Treasury provides necessary
support for such services as fleet management and maintenance, internal
audit, telecommunications, postal and printing services, as well as
management of numerous interdepartmental accounts.
Under Director Chuck Chianese, the Division has actively sought and
implemented common sense economies in multiple areas and for multiple
agencies. When the Department of Human Services, for example, had an
immediate need for additional vehicles for 160 new DYFS caseworkers,
Treasury conducted an evaluation of its automobile fleet and recalled
vehicles from all departments of state government to meet it. So rather
than purchase new automobiles at a per-car cost of $11,000 through
the State's vehicle contract, we reorganized the motor pool in a way
that assisted both DYFS and the taxpayer.
The Division’s recent accomplishments include the initiation
of a contract for an outside firm to audit the telecommunications services
provided to the State and look for possible overcharges and savings
opportunities. The review has resulted in savings of $2.4 million to
date.
In addition, the Division also realized approximately $7 million on
cost offsets by signing consolidated contracts that lock in the price
for the supply of electricity and gas for State agencies and other
public entities.
The Division of Taxation, under the direction of Robert Thompson,
has worked extremely effectively at recouping tax liabilities due to
the State. For the fourth consecutive fiscal year, compliance collections
have reached an all-time high. Based on current trends, the Division
expects that Compliance Collections will exceed $1.1 billion for FY
2005, which represents an increase in excess of 70 percent over FY
2001. The Division attributes this growth in productivity to the support
of the administration in continuing to fund compliance and enforcement
activities and resources, in addition to implementing new, effective
initiatives.
Another example of integrating efficiencies is the Division’s
expanded electronic filing program for the Sales and Use Tax, which
was introduced in January 2004. This efficient, user-friendly system
reduces paper filings and the inherent costs associated with processing
paper forms. In FY 2005, the number of sales tax transactions filed
electronically has increased from 4,000 to 100,000 in the most recent
quarter. It is expected that the remaining paper filings will be eliminated
by the end of this calendar year.
Our automated income tax filing systems continue to break records
of participation, which translates to record dollars being saved through
electronic integration.
The State reached another record milestone in electronic filing for
the 2004 tax season – more than 1.5 million returns, or a 52
percent increase over last year. And when you consider that New Jersey
saves $1 for every return processed electronically versus paper returns,
the economies are significant and tangible for the state taxpayer.
In Fiscal 2006, the Division of Revenue plans to build on this achievement
by working with Taxation and the Department of Labor to make paperless
filing and payment the predominate mode of processing for our individual
income tax returns and to convert the entire quarterly employer return
and payment process to an electronic format. Those changes will help
us avoid over $1 million per year in forms production, mailing, and
processing costs.
The Division of Taxation is also making substantial progress enforcing
the tax laws regarding Internet sales of cigarettes. Between November
2004 and February 2005, Division agents seized the contents of several
plane loads of cigarettes that were shipped from several European countries
into Newark Liberty International Airport. For the current fiscal year
to date, seizures of contraband cigarettes have increased by 32 percent.
72,100 cartoons were seized resulting in an averted tax loss of $1
million. The Division also worked in cooperation with the U.S. Attorneys
Office in the Eastern District of Virginia in a federal prosecution,
which resulted in billing 1,250 people for $800,000 for failure to
pay cigarette tax and use tax for purchases of cigarettes over the
Internet. Most of this revenue has been recouped and this enforcement
effort continues for those who have not complied.
We feel these actions have had a positive result in discouraging illegal
internet purchases. We recently received information that a major tobacco
manufacturer conducted a poll which shows that cigarette purchases
over the Internet by New Jersey residents have decreased by 33 percent
from the last 3 months of 2004 to the first 3 months of 2005.
The Division of Revenue’s mission is to provide responsive,
accurate, and cost-effective transaction processing, revenue recording,
debt collection, image processing and business-registry services. On
an annual basis, the Division processes approximately 24 million transactions,
deposits nearly $25 billion in payments, and captures up to 20 million
electronic images of processed returns and remittance documents.
In the past year, the Division has implemented enhancements to streamline
the business gateway web site. The one-stop service site -- which facilitates
business formation and registration -- now allows contractors interested
in doing business with the State to use information they have entered
on the gateway to automatically access and pre-fill forms for several
related programs. Items integrated into this service include the small
business registration application, forms for contractor classification
and prevailing-wage compliance, the bidders’ list application,
form W9, and the educational facilities contractor-classification application.
In addition, public sector contractors can look up their registration
status online through a new web-based proof of registration service.
Businesses may also now file their annual reports online. The new
annual report service consolidates the reporting process, which was
split between two paper-based and labor-intensive systems. These enhancements
will improve the quality and timeliness of our commercial-information
programs.
The Division administers an effective centralized debt collection
program that currently brings in over $130 million in revenue and another
$34 million in set-offs this fiscal year. The majority of this debt
would not have been collected if not for this centralized program.
The Division of Property Management and Construction (DPMC) has responsibilities
that include the procurement and administration of design and construction
contracts and leases in accordance with competitive bidding laws, as
well as the management of approximately 350 leases and 40 State-owned
buildings.
Under the leadership of Director Ed Jenkins, the Division has implemented
a number of lease savings initiatives. Elimination of costly month-to-month
leases and more efficient use of space identified in existing state-owned
or leased facilities has resulted in approximately $1.7 million of
annual rent savings and the avoidance of nearly $2 million in future
lease costs. Language added to the budget authorizing the Division
to renegotiate leases at more favorable terms has resulted in annual
rent savings of more than $800,000 and cost avoidance of more than
$5 million for renovations that will be performed by landlords.
During the recent major flooding in Trenton last September and most
recently in April, the Division did an outstanding job. Their proactive
measures prior to the flooding preserved hundreds of thousands of dollars
worth of equipment and property in the Capitol Complex, particularly
the State House Garage and ensured the safety of those fighting the
flood waters. They worked together to find creative methods to maintain
and re-start building services to keep the State House and other facilities
open for business.
This past fiscal year the Division of Purchase and Property implemented
various cutting-edge electronic procurement efficiencies and major
reforms. Under the leadership of Jack Naiman, the Purchase Bureau is
responsible for over 700 contracts and awards contracts valued in excess
of $1.5 billion annually that serve the functional needs of government.
The Division introduced electronic bidding and received its first
electronic bid in January 2005 as part of the e-Bid pilot program.
Online services were also improved through the Division’s newly
designed Web site, which now includes more information for the vendor
community including; anticipated advertisements, 6 month forecasting
and a direct link to assist in identifying small businesses registered
with the NJ Commerce Economic Growth & Tourism Commission.
The Division of Contract Compliance and Equal Employment Opportunity
in Public Contracts, under the direction of Deirdre Webster Cobb, is
charged with monitoring and enforcing New Jersey’s laws against
discrimination as they relate to government contracting.
The Division recently readopted it rules with amendments in order to
strengthen the requirements with which public agencies, contractors,
subcontractors and business firms must comply in order to ensure equal
employment opportunity in public contracting. Of particular note are
the changes to the training rules that will ensure that one-half of
one percent of the total cost of a construction project is readily
available to finance minority and worker outreach and training programs.
As a result of these changes, during FY 06, it is anticipated that
more funding will be available to train minorities and women in the
construction trades and qualify them for employment on public contracts.
Enhanced enforcement efforts through sanctioning and public education
have resulted in an increase in minority and female utilization in
public contracting.
The Division of Pensions and Benefits, under the direction of Fred
Beaver, administers the second-largest non-federal public-benefits
program in the nation. More than 700,000 individuals participate in
the various retirement systems and over 800,000 lives are covered under
the State Health Benefits Program.
The Division is in the process of expanding a Web-based system that
will allow employers to determine the processing status of forms submitted
to pensions and benefits without the need to contact employees. In
addition, the Division is also undertaking an effort to deploy pension
and health benefit information to active and retired members via the
Web.
In response to a State auditor report, the Division has developed
procedures to more closely monitor post-retirement earnings in conjunction
with the Department of Labor and the Office of Information Technology.
Since 2002, this monitoring has led to the assessment and recouping
$1.6 million in overpayments due to deaths of retirees and fraud.
In addition, the division has developed procedures to monitor disability
retiree earning following recommendations from the auditor. Since 2002,
Pensions has assessed $1.1 million in overpaid benefits.
The Division of Investment, under director William Clark, is responsible
for the management of State assets, managing 187 funds with a total
market value of $80 billion. The State’s pension funds currently
have a market value of $69.5 billion
As this committee is well aware, the Investment Council has approved
an alternative investment policy to provide for the investment of up
to 13 percent of the pension portfolio into alternative asset classes.
We have engaged consultants to provide the State guidance for investments
in two classes – real estate and private equity – and are
in the final stages of selecting a third consultant for absolute returns.
We believe this diversification is critically important to mitigate
the State’s risk and enhance returns in support of the pension
fund.
The Office of Public Finance is the unit responsible for the issuance
of all State general obligation debt, both short and long term and
of all State-backed debt issued by State authorities. Led by Ann Flynn,
Public Finance is constantly monitoring the bond market for additional
refinancing opportunities as interest rates continue to fluctuate.
In the past fiscal year, the Office of Public Finance completed 24
bond transactions including several refinancing bond issues. As a result
of the strong tax-exempt bond market and low interest rates, the State
achieved significant debt service savings of approximately $88 million
in FY 05 and additional savings of approximately $207 million in FY
06.
The New Jersey Lottery, under the leadership of Director Michellene
Davis, is continuing to build on the record year experienced in FY
2004 when it contributed more than $794 million to the State Treasury
to benefit education and institutions. Through the first eight months
of FY2005, total ticket sales have increased more than 3.6 percent
over the prior fiscal year. For FY 2006, we anticipate that the Lottery,
New Jersey 4th largest revenue generator, will deposit another record
amount of funds to the budget -- $820 million.
When you consider that this division of Treasury is operated on a
budget of $30 million, and will generate about $800 million in projected
revenue to the State budget, the New Jersey Lottery is one of the most
efficiently run lotteries in the country. For every dollar spent on
operational costs, our lottery generates $27.67 in revenue for education
and institutions.
Under the direction of Charlene Holzbaur, the Office of Management
and Budget continues to set an example in the efficiency of its own
operation. With a workforce of 183, OMB now operates with 31 fewer
staff than it did five years ago, a 14 percent reduction. In fact,
OMB’s employs less than half of the number of workers it employed
in 1988. Major programs such as budget planning were consolidated and
others were eliminated altogether as the agency concentrated on its
core areas of budget operations, accounting, payroll and financial
reporting.
Treasury continues to seek ways to cut costs, operate more efficiency,
work smarter and perform to the highest of ethical standards. There
are several initiatives that we believe will have an immediate positive
impact in these areas for FY 2006 and beyond and lighten the load that
taxpayers carry for the cost of government at both the state and local
level.
The Division of Purchase and Property is moving ahead with Governor
Codey’s effort to save State and local government money by buying
smarter through a new “strategic sourcing” initiative.
Recently, a consultant was hired to develop a plan to strategically
coordinate the purchase of equipment, goods and services by State and
local entities to leverage the combined buying power and realize maximum
savings. The New Jersey State government purchases more than $1.5 billion
worth of services each year, which does not include contract purchases
by 1,800 local entities. Just a small percentage of savings has the
potential to yield tens of millions of dollars in economies on the
purchase of goods and services statewide, and at least some of those
savings will be achieved in FY 2006.
The State of New Jersey Distribution Center is a centralized warehouse
operated for purchase and distribution of food and other materials
used by State agencies. Operating under the Division of Purchase and
property, the warehouse is a place where bulk purchased items are stored
at the warehouse site and then shipped out to individual agencies at
a marked up price to offset administrative costs.
While it was an efficient idea when it was first implemented, today
most supplies can be purchased at office supply or other bulk package
vendors at competitive prices and be shipped directly to agency offices.
By eliminating this middle management of goods at our current warehouse,
we project an initial savings of more than $2 million from avoided
rent and administrative expenses.
In Fiscal 2006, the Division of Revenue plans to develop a comprehensive
process for the systematic and timely transfer of all non-tax agency
debt to the Division. Also, we will implement a new and enhanced data
base management system that will better enable the Motor Vehicle Commission
collect surcharges due to the State as part of its non-tax debt collection
program.
Also as part of Treasury’s ongoing efforts to save money and
find efficiencies, we have retained a consultant to conduct a study
of our Bureau of Risk Management operations. The study, which is being
done at no charge by a consortium of 18 local joint insurance funds,
will help correct the deficiencies cited by a State audit. The audit,
which was done between July 1, 2002 and August 26, 2004, discovered
weaknesses in the coordination of benefits between workers compensation
and the sick leave injury program, which provides continuation of pay
for one year from the initial date of an injury.
The audit found that the bureau lacks a centralized system for oversight
of claims and collections from others responsible for damages to the
State, its employees and property.
This is a 90-day study that will yield recommendations that we’re
prepared to implement immediately to streamline the process for reporting,
reviewing and administering claims, and improve the process at agencies
to reduce work-related injuries
And, last for FY 2006, but certainly not least; the Division of Taxation
is prepared to move forward with the long awaited Property Assessment
Management System – PAMS.
PAMS, to begin on a three county, phase-in schedule, will provide
a centralized, web-based system with multiple capabilities for municipalities
to access information and state taxation services.
It will replace the antiquated MOD-4 system, and eliminate between
$12 million and $15 million per year in system costs to localities
for assessment information services. It will create one central database
of information for real property information and all tax and parcel
information will be available in one application.
Finally, I must acknowledge what a pleasure it has been during the
past four years to work with the team we have assembled in the Department
of Treasury. Every day, the division directors and staff members perform
their job duties with professionalism and dedication. I am proud to
work with them and would like to thank all of them, as well as Deputy
Treasurers Dave Rousseau and Robert Smartt, Chief of Staff Carol Ehrlich,
Associate Deputy Treasurer Chuck Chianese, Assistant Treasurers Dan
Levine and Gerry Gibbs and Communications Director Tom Vincz.
At this time, I would invite questions from the committee on my presentation.