Governor Phil Murphy • Lt. Governor Tahesha Way

2014 Decisions

January

February

March

April

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF DOMINIC COSTANZO, SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE BOROUGH OF LEBANON, HUNTERDON COUNTY, 4/4/14, (#142-14)
» OAL Decision for #142-14

LOVING CARE AGENCY, INC. AND K.S. AND K.A., on behalf of minor child, A.A.V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF TRENTON, MERCER COUNTY, 4/7/14, (#144-14)
» OAL Decision for #144-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE WESTWOOD REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, BERGEN COUNTY V. RUSSELL MILLER, 4/7/14, (#145-14)
» OAL Decision for #145-14

E.H., on behalf of minor children, E.H. AND J.H. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF NORTH BRUNSWICK, MIDDLESEX COUNTY, 4/7/14, (#146-14)
» OAL Decision for #146-14

BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE VINELAND PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL AND ANN MURPHY-GARCIA V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, OFFICE OF FISCAL ACCOUNTABILITY AND COMPLIANCE, 4/4/14, (#148-14)

TROY JACKSON V. STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF CAMDEN, CAMDEN COUNTY, 4/10/14, (#151-14)
» OAL Decision for #151-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWN OF BOONTON, MORRIS COUNTY V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF WHARTON, MORRIS COUNTY, 4/10/14, (#154-14)
» OAL Decision for #154-14

G.H. AND E.H., on behalf of minor child, K.H. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF FRANKLIN LAKES, BERGEN COUNTY, 4/10/14, (#157-14)

BOE OF THE BORO. OF INTERLAKEN, MONMOUTH CO. V. BOE OF THE CITY OF ASBURY PARK, MONMOUTH CO., BOE OF THE BORO. OF WEST LONG BRANCH, MONMOUTH CO. & BOE OF SHORE REG. SCH. DIST., MONMOUTH CO.   AND   M.L., o/b/m, J.F. & D.F.; E.O. AND7 B.O., o/b/m, D.O. & G.O.; J.P. & M.P., o/b/m, A.P. & M.P.; L.R. & M.R., o/b/m, S.R. & F.R. V. BOE OF THE BORO. OF INTERLAKEN, MONMOUTH CO., BOE OF THE CITY OF ASBURY PARK, MONMOUTH CO., BOE OF THE BORO. OF WEST LONG BRANCH, MONMOUTH CO. & BOE OF THE SHORE REG. SCH. DIST, MONMOUTH CO. (Consolidated), 4/21/14, (#162-14)
» OAL Decision for #162-14

CHANCELLOR ACADEMY V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, DIVISION OF FINANCE, 4/24/14, (#168-14)
» OAL Decision for #168-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF JOSEPH GRECO, SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE BOROUGH OF PARK RIDGE, BERGEN COUNTY, 4/24/14, (#169-14)

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF ANDREW DAZZ, SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF JERSEY CITY, HUDSON COUNTY, 4/28/14, (#172-14)

May

A.B., on behalf of minor child, L.M.D-R V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF BURLINGTON, BURLINGTON COUNTY, 5/2/14, (#180-14)
» OAL Decision for #180-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE CERTIFICATES OF P.S., NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 5/2/14, (#182-14A) (STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS APPEAL)

I.J., on behalf of minor child, Q.J. v. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HAMILTON, MERCER COUNTY, 5/2/14, (#183-14B)
» OAL Decision for #183-14B

YVETTE JOHNSON-DEEN V. STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF NEWARK, ESSEX COUNTY, 5/5/14, (#187-14)
» OAL Decision for #187-14

BERNARDS TOWNSHIP EDUCATION ASSOCIATION V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF BERNARDS, SOMERSET COUNTY, 5/5/14, (#190-14)
» OAL Decision for #190-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF HAWTHORNE, PASSAIC COUNTY V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF PROSPECT PARK, PASSAIC COUNTY AND NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, 5/12/14, (#196-14)
» OAL Decision for #196-14

HATIKVAH INTERNATIONAL ACADEMY CHARTER SCHOOL V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND EVO POPOFF, 5/13/14, (#199-14) (EMERGENT RELIEF)
» OAL Decision for #199-14

D.U.E. SEASON CHARTER SCHOOL, DORIS CARPENTER AND E.B. V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND EVO POPOFF, 5/13/14 (#201-14) (EMERGENT RELIEF)

IN THE MATTER OF THE SUSPENSION OF THE TEACHING CERTIFICATE OF GISELE AUGUSTE-WASHINGTON, SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF HOBOKEN, HUDSON COUNTY, 5/13/14, (#202-14)

RICHARD SCHEMPP V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGHT OF CLAYTON, GLOUCESTER COUNTY, 5/12/14, (#204-14)
» OAL Decision for #204-14

E.H., on behalf of minor child, G.H. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF OCEAN CITY, CAPE MAY COUNTY, 5/16/14, (#207-14)
» OAL Decision for #207-14

J.L., on behalf of minor child, J.L.-C. V. BOARD OF THE TOWNSHIP OF EWING, MERCER COUNTY, 5/19/14, (#213-14)
» OAL Decision for #213-14

SHALOM ACADEMY CHARTER SCHOOL, BERGEN COUNTY V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, 5/19/14, (#214-14)
» OAL Decision for #214-14

CHRISTINE LOPAC V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF MANVILLE, SOMERSET COUNTY, 5/27/14, (#224-14)
» OAL Decision for #224-14

KELLY LACIK V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF EDISON, MIDDLESEX COUNTY, 5/27/14, (226-14)
» OAL Decision for 226-14

June

IN RE  PETITION FOR EQUITABLE MODIFICATION OF THE COST APPORTIONMENT FOR THE RIVER DELL REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, BERGEN COUNTY, 6/2/14, (#231-14)
» OAL Decision for #231-14

DAVID HERRON V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF MONTCLAIR, ESSEX COUNTY, 6/2/14, (#233-14)
» OAL Decision for #233-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF LONGPORT, ATLANTIC COUNTY V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF ATLANTIC CITY, ATLANTIC COUNTY AND BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF OCEAN CITY, CAPE MAY COUNTY, 6/5/14, (#238-14)
» OAL Decision for #238-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE SUSPENSION OF THE TEACHING CERTIFICATE OF ANGELA NORWARD, STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF CAMDEN, CAMDEN COUNTY, 6/6/14, (#239-14)

W.H., III, on behalf of minor children, W.B.H. AND X.Q.H. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF EWING, MERCER COUNTY, 6/6/14, (#240-14)
» OAL Decision for #240-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE CERTIFICATES OF DONALD SALAAM, NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 6/6/14, (#241-14A)  (APPEAL DECISION)
» SBE Decision for #241-14A

IN THE MATTER OF THE SUSPENSION OF THE TEACHING CERTIFICATE OF AMIR McNAIR, NORTH HUDSON ACADEMY, HUDSON COUNTY, 6/6/14, (#242-14)

KAREN GABA V. NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 6/10/14, (#250-14A)

JAMES MESSNER AND ROBERT CONDO V. STACY GRAY, BOARD OF EDUC. OF THE TWP. OF DEPTFORD, GLOUCESTER CO.   AND   WALTER BERGLUND V. STACY GRAY, BOARD OF EDUC. OF THE TWP. OF DEPTFORD, GLOUCESTER CO., 6/9/14, (#243-14ASEC)
» SEC Decision for #243-14ASEC

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF SANFORD WILLIAMS, STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF NEWARK, ESSEX COUNTY, 6/6/14, (#246-14)

MICHELLE LONGO-SARE V. STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF NEWARK, ESSEX COUNTY, 6/10/14, (#249-14)

MELINDO PERSI V. DANIEL WOSKA, BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF BRICK, OCEAN COUNTY, 6/17/14, (#260-14A)   SEC APPEAL DECISION
» SEC Decision for #260-14A

CATHERINE RUTLEDGE V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF BETHLEHEM, HUNTERDON COUNTY, 6/19/14, (#264-14)

JOSEPH M. ANNECCHINO V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF IRVINGTON, ESSEX COUNTY, 6/24/14, (#267-14)
» OAL Decision for #267-14

D.B., on behalf of minor child, E.B. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE, ESSEX COUNTY, 6/25/14, (#270-14)

ELIZABETH MARCINEK V. NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 6/25/14, (#274-14)
» OAL Decision for #274-14

July

M.R., on behalf of minor child, B.R. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE EAST WINDSOR REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, MERCER COUNTY, 7/11/14, (#289-14)

LUCY WALKER AND JANET POINSETTE V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, BERGEN COUNTY AND DONALD CARLISLE, ENGLEWOOD SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT, 7/11/14, (#290-14)

MILDRED WAALE V. NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 7/14/14, (#293-14)
» OAL Decision for #293-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE SUSPENSION OF THE TEACHING CERTIFICATE OF LaWANNA McCLEASE, STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF CAMDEN, CAMDEN COUNTY, 7/16/14, (#296-14)

BOE OF THE BORO. OF INTERLAKEN, MONMOUTH CO. V. BOE OF THE CITY OF ASBURY PARK, MONMOUTH CO.;  BOE OF THE BORO. OF WEST LONG BRANCH, MONMOUTH CO. & BOE OF SHORE REG. S.D., MONMOUTH CO.   AND   M.L., o/b/m, J.F. & D.F.;  E.O. & B.O., o/b/m, D.O. & G.O.;  J.P. & M.P., o/b/m, A.P. & M.P.;  L.R. & M.R., o/b/m, S.R. & F.R. V. BOE OF THE BORO. OF INTERLAKEN, MONMOUTH CO.;  BOE OF THE CITY OF ASBURY PARK, MONMOUTH CO.;  BOE OF THE BORO. OF WEST LONG BRANCH, MONMOUTH CO. & BOE OF THE SHORE REG. S.D., MONMOUTH CO.  (Consolidated) (Summary Decision), 7/17/14, (#298-14)
» OAL Decision for #298-14
» DOE Decision for #298-14

L.A.A., Sr., on behalf of minor child, L.A.A., Jr. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF BLOOMFIELD, ESSEX COUNTY, 7/17/14, (#299-14)

WAYNE CALANDRIELLO V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE SOUTH ORANGE-MAPLEWOOD SCHOOL DISTRICT, ESSEX COUNTY, 7/17/14, (#300-14)
» OAL Decision for #300-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF LOUIS MELILLO, SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF ELIZABETH, UNION COUNTY, 7/24/14, (#308-14R)

MYLES HART V. NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 7/29/14, (#309-14)
» OAL Decision for #309-14

M.P., on behalf of minor child, K.K. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE MORRIS HILLS REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, MORRIS COUNTY, 7/29/14, (#310-14)
» OAL Decision for #310-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWN OF HAMMONTON, ATLANTIC COUNTY V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF GLOUCESTER, CAMDEN COUNTY, 7/31/14, (#311-14)
» OAL Decision for #311-14

August

AAA SCHOOL, LLC V. PASSAIC COUNTY EDUCATIONAL SERVICES COMMISSION, PASSAIC COUNTY, 8/4/14, (#314-14)
» OAL Decision for #314-14

M.O'K. AND S.O'K., on behalf of minor children, K.O'K., A.O'K. AND C.O'K. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF CRESSKILL, BERGEN COUNTY AND BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF LITTLE FERRY, BERGEN COUNTY, 8/12/14, (#325-14)
» OAL Decision for #325-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF RIDGEFIELD, BERGEN COUNTY V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, SCOTT E. RIXFORD, INTERIM EXECUTIVE COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT, BERGEN COUNTY, 8/8/14, (#326-14)
» OAL Decision for #326-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE CERTIFICATE OF QUINCEY HOLLOWAY, NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS,  8/5/14, (#329-14A)  (APPEAL DECISION)
» SBE Decision for APPEAL DECISION

R.N., on behalf of minor child, A.N. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE UPPER FREEHOLD REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, MONMOUTH COUNTY, 8/14/14, (#333-14)
» OAL Decision for #333-14

BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE PASSAIC COUNTY ELKS CEREBRAL PALSY CENTER V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, OFFICE OF FISCAL ACCOUNTABILITY AND COMPLIANCE, 8/14/14, (#334-14)
» OAL Decision for #334-14

KEITH ANDREWS V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE RAMAPO INDIAN HILLS REGIONAL HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT, BERGEN COUNTY, 8/21/14, (#340-14)
» OAL Decision for #340-14

DAVID KELLY V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCA-TION, CRIMINAL HISTORY UNIT AND BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF LAWRENCE, MERCER COUNTY, 8/21/14, (#344-14)
» OAL Decision for #344-14

AAA SCHOOL LLC/EL ELDESOUKY V. PASSAIC COUNTY EDUCATIONAL SERVICES COMMISSION, PASSAIC COUNTY, 8/25/14, (#347-14)
» OAL Decision for #347-14

September

October

K.F., on behalf of minor children, T.B. AND K.B. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE HUNTERDON CENTRAL REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, HUNTERDON COUNTY, 10/2/14, (#409-14)
» OAL Decision for #409-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HAMILTON, MERCER COUNTY V. M.J., on behalf of minor children, C.J. AND C.J., 10/7/14, (#410-14)  (DOCKET JUDGMENT)

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HAMILTON, MERCER COUNTY V. S.B., on behalf of minor child, C.B., 10/7/14, (#411-14)  (DOCKET JUDGMENT)

IN THE MATTER OF BARBARA GARRITY, BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HOLMDEL, MONMOUTH COUNTY, 10/14/14, (#414-14)
» SEC Decision for #414-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOMS RIVER REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, OCEAN COUNTY V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CENTRAL REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, OCEAN COUNTY, 10/14/14, (#415-14)
» OAL Decision for #415-14

BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF NEW MILFORD, BERGEN COUNTY V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, 10/14/14, (#416-14)
» OAL Decision for #416-14

AAA SCHOOL, LLC AND EL SAYED ELDESOUKY V. PASSAIC COUNTY EDUCATIONAL SERVICE COMMISSION, PASSAIC COUNTY, 10/16/14, (#419-14)
» OAL Decision for #419-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF EDWARD NEWTON, STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF NEWARK, ESSEX COUNTY, 10/28/14, (#433-14)

R.P., on behalf of minor child, A.P. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HAINESPORT, BURLINGTON COUNTY, 10/23/14, (#436-14)
» OAL Decision for #436-14

N.J., on behalf of minor child, J.J. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF UNION, UNION COUNTY, 10/27/14, (#437-14)
» OAL Decision for #437-14

K.G., on behalf of minor child, M.K.E. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE, ESSEX COUNTY, 10/29/14, (#440-14)
» OAL Decision for #440-14

MATTHEW MIGNANELLI V. NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 10/29/14, (#441-14)
» OAL Decision for #441-14

SHERRY MORENCY V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HAMILTON, MERCER COUNTY, 10/29/14, (#442-14)
» OAL Decision for #442-14

November

December

TIA CASTILLO V. NEW JERSEY STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, CRIMINAL HISTORY REVIEW UNIT, 12/1/14, (#470-14)

IN THE MATTER OF THE TENURE HEARING OF BETHANY DOYLE-TAYLOR, SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF BAYONNE, HUDSON COUNTY, 12/2/14, (#473-14)

TAMMY LANE V. STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF PATERSON, PASSAIC COUNTY, 12/5/14, (#475-14)
» OAL Decision for #475-14

IN THE MATTER OF THE CERTIFICATES OF MICHAEL BONSU, NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 12/5/14, (#476-14A)
» SBE Decision for #476-14A

S.Y., on behalf of minor children, E.Y. AND ET AL. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF WYCKOFF, BERGEN COUNTY, 12/15/14, (#484-14)
» OAL Decision for #484-14

IN THE MATTER OF RHONDA WILLIAMS BEMBRY, BOARD MEMBER, BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF HACKENSACK, BERGEN COUNTY, 12/15/14, (#487-14SEC)
» SEC Decision for #487-14SEC

AAA SCHOOL LLC/EL ELDESOUKY V. PASSAIC COUNTY EDUCATIONAL SERVICES COMMISSION, PASSAIC COUNTY, 12/18/14, (#489-14)

ROSALYND SMITH V. STATE-OPERATED SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF PATERSON, PASSAIC COUNTY, 12/18/14, (#491-14)

R.C.P. JR., on behalf of minor children, J.P. and J.P. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF HILLSIDE, UNION COUNTY, 12/223/14, (#494-14)
» OAL Decision for #494-14

M.H., on behalf of minor children, M.L., J.L. AND X.L. V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF BOGOTA, BERGEN COUNTY, 12/23/14, (#496-14)
» OAL Decision for #496-14

JESSICA WALDER V. NEW JERSEY STATE BOARD OF EXAMINERS, 12/29/14, (#503-14)
» OAL Decision for #503-14

MARY McKENNEDY V. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE BOROUGH OF BRIELLE, MONMOUTH COUNTY, 12/29/14, (#504-14)
» OAL Decision for #504-14