The Promising Practices Project

The Promising Practices study analyzed the practices and activities that bolstered student learning and their positive effect on student performance in ELA and mathematics on the New Jersey State Learning Assessments (NJSLA). The study explored how individual schools successfully served all students’ needs, with special attention paid to practices that lead to growth in student groups often understood to underperform.

Promising Practices Identification Procedure

NJ Promising Practice Schools 2024. Outline of the state of New Jersey showing blue circles for Elementary, orange for Middle, and green for High School.

The research team identified positive outlier schools based on the Department’s School Performance Reports, student demographic/testing data, and NCES socioeconomic files. Using statistical models that compared predicted and actual performance, the research team selected a sample of schools blindly (i.e., without school names identified) that exceeded expected student learning outcomes for all students and/or for some disaggregated groups of students (i.e., multilingual learners, students with disabilities, economically disadvantaged students, etc.).

After the quantitative analysis, the Rutgers research team focused on 52 New Jersey schools from 47 LEAs statewide with identified positive learning outcomes when comparing pre- to post-pandemic performance in ELA and mathematics.

The Rutgers research team worked with the identified LEAs to uncover innovative, promising practices that significantly impacted students’ academic performance. Three of the identified practices are featured below, while the details of the research project, full set of reports, and additional information can be found at Rutgers University’s Promising Practices Project webpage.

Caroline L. Reutter School, Township of Franklin School District, Gloucester County 

Caroline L. Reutter School’s students ranked in the top 10% of middle and high school math performance statewide. When asked what accounts for such success, Reutter educators pointed to a model for teaching math developed by a district math coach that provides tiered intervention and remediation across grades K–6. Student placements are determined by universal screeners that detect each learner’s math fluency and skills (i.e., rapid recall of math facts and appropriate strategies). Identified students are enrolled in Tier 2 and Tier 3 classrooms that follow a structured daily plan: (1) a strategy-based lesson determined by the students’ diagnostic assessment scores, (2) a standard-based lesson from the grade-level curriculum, and (3) fundamental fluency goals, or goal groups, during which each student receives targeted instruction based on their goals. This school also developed a Tier 1.5 for “bubble kids” who receive push-in math support to prevent them from needing Tier 2 instruction in the future.

Sara M. Gilmore Academy, Union City School District, Hudson County 

Union City School District has tailored a bilingual instruction program to better meet the needs of its primarily multilingual student population. The program was designed to be culturally responsive and linguistically inclusive, offering students instruction in both their native language and in English. The goal was not just to teach English as a second language, but to support bilingualism as an asset, allowing students to develop literacy in both languages simultaneously. Newcomers with minimal English language proficiency are placed in a "port of entry" program, where instruction is provided entirely in Spanish. Students are then placed in an ML course. As opposed to some other districts, Union City has developed a bridge course where the general education curriculum is taught by a bilingual instructor instead of directly placing students into English language mainstream courses or solely relying on ML courses. The bilingual instructor of the bridge course is skilled in monitoring and addressing students' linguistic challenges, making the content accessible while gradually integrating English language learning. 

International Middle School, Cherry Hill School District, Camden County 

Students at Rosa International Middle School outperformed both the district and state in the NJSLA for mathematics in 2018–19 and 2021–22; their performance placed them in the top 30% of middle and high schools for SWDs. Their students with Individualized Education Plans (IEPs) also performed better than expected in both years. Rosa educators shared their efforts to enroll eighth-grade students with IEPs in algebra, which has been difficult to offer in the past due to co-teaching needs. Students with IEPs are supported through a consultative model in which the algebra teacher meets with a special education teacher once per week to plan IEP-driven accommodations. The math department recently created a “hybrid” seventh- and eighth-grade inclusion class that “compacts all of the seventh-grade curriculum and specific elements of the eighth-grade curriculum.” According to the Principal, this new course will “help... with [making] recommendations for [in- class resource] students and potentially resource students to go into eighth-grade algebra.” 

2024 List of Identified Schools

County School District School Name
Bergen Bergenfield Borough School District Hoover Elementary School
Bergen Garfield Public School District Woodrow Wilson School #5
Bergen Lodi School District Roosevelt School
Essex Caldwell-West Caldwell School District Lincoln Elementary School
Essex Newark Public School District University High School
Essex Orange Board of Education School District Orange Prep Academy School of Inquiry and Innovation
Hudson Hoboken Public School District Joseph F Brandt Elementary School
Hudson Union City School District Sara M. Gilmore Academy
Morris Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District Mount Tabor Elementary School
Passaic Passaic City School District Passaic Gifted and Talented Academy School #20
Passaic Passaic City School District Passaic Preparatory Academy
Passaic Paterson Public School District School 28
Passaic Paterson Public School District Charles J. Riley, School 9
Passaic Wayne Township Public School District Packanack Elementary School
Passaic West Milford Township Public School District Upper Greenwood Lake Elementary School
Sussex Hamburg School District Hamburg School
Union Cranford Public School District Orange Avenue School
Union Elizabeth Public Schools Elmora School No. 12
Union Plainfield Public School District Dewitt D. Barlow Elementary School
Union Plainfield Public School District Frederic W. Cook Elementary School
Union Roselle Public School District Harrison Elementary School
Union College Achieve Central Charter School College Achieve Central Charter School
Warren North Warren Regional School District North Warren Regional School

County School District School Name
Hunterdon Flemington-Raritan Regional School District Reading-Fleming Intermediate School
Mercer Princeton Charter School Princeton Charter School
Middlesex Woodbridge Township School District Oak Tree Road Elementary School
Middlesex Woodbridge Township School District Robert Mascenik Elementary School
Monmouth College Achieve Greater Asbury Park Charter School College Achieve Greater Asbury Park Charter School
Monmouth Hazlet Township Public School District Middle Road School
Monmouth Middletown Township Public School District Navesink Elementary School
Ocean Berkeley Township School District H & M Potter School
Ocean Brick Township Public School District Brick Township Memorial High School
Ocean Lacey Township School District Cedar Creek Elementary School
Somerset Bound Brook School District Community Middle School
Somerset North Plainfield School District North Plainfield Middle School
Somerset South Bound Brook Public School District Robert Morris School

County School District School Name
Atlantic Atlantic City School District Chelsea Heights School
Atlantic Galloway Township Public School District Reeds Road Elementary School
Atlantic Greater Egg Harbor Regional High School District Oakcrest High School
Camden Cherry Hill School District Rosa International Middle School
Camden Haddonfield School District Central School
Cape May Ocean City School District Ocean City High School
Cape May Lower Cape May Regional School District Richard M. Teitelman Middle School
Cumberland Millville School District Rieck Avenue Elementary School
Cumberland Vineland Public School District Marie Durand Elementary School
Gloucester Gateway Regional High School District Gateway Regional High School
Gloucester Monroe Township Public School District Radix Elementary
Gloucester Swedesboro-Woolwich School District Walter Hill School
Gloucester Township of Franklin School District Caroline L. Reutter School
Gloucester Washington Township School District Birches Elementary School
Gloucester Washington Township School District Whitman Elementary School
Gloucester Deptford Township Public School District Good Intent Elementary School